Baking Resources
Home › Guides

Easy Christmas Cookies: One Simple Dough, Three Kinds of Cookies

Baking Resources Editorial · Reviewed by Joan Ramos · Updated November 2026 · 7 min read

Easy Christmas Cookies: One Dough, 3 Cookies + 20 Picks

The easiest Christmas cookies start with one simple butter dough. Make it once, split it three ways, and you get three cookies for the price of one: jam thumbprints, sprinkle rounds and chocolate pinwheels. It's seven pantry ingredients, no rolling pin or cookie cutters, and no fancy decorating.

One batch makes 4 dozen cookies (16 of each kind). Plan on about 2 1/4 hours start to finish, with about 50 minutes of hands-on time. The rest is chilling, baking and cooling.

The card below works the batch for you. Pick 2, 6 or 12 dozen and the amounts update. After the card, you'll find 20 more easy Christmas cookie picks, a beginner's game plan and tips for making them ahead.

Jump to the recipe card ↓

Recipe card

One-Dough Christmas Cookies, Three Ways (Thumbprints, Sprinkle Rounds and Pinwheels) recipe

Pick your which cookies and how many you need. Every amount, the bake time and your start time update for you.

Why this one dough makes Christmas baking easy

Don't want three kinds? Make all 48 as sprinkle rounds or all thumbprints. The card's "which cookies" menu has that option.

A beginner's game plan for Christmas cookie day

  1. Take the butter out early. Soft butter should dent when you press it but not look greasy. About an hour on the counter usually does it.
  2. Make the dough and the pinwheel log first. The log needs 30 minutes in the fridge, so get it in there before you shape anything else.
  3. Shape the rounds and thumbprints while the log chills. They can go straight into the oven.
  4. Bake one tray at a time on the middle rack. It's slower, but every cookie bakes evenly.
  5. Use cool trays. A hot tray melts the butter before the cookie sets, and they spread. Rotate two or three trays, or run the bottom of a warm one under cold water and dry it.

Not sure when they're done? Look for set edges and lightly golden bottoms, with pale tops. Our guide on how to tell when cookies are done shows the signs.

Baking guideHow to Tell When Cookies Are Done: 5 Reliable SignsSee the doneness test →

20 more easy Christmas cookies to try

Once you've got the one-dough trio down, here are 20 more easy Christmas cookie recipes. They're sorted from easiest to "a little more effort," and every one is beginner-friendly.

Super easy (no chilling, no special tools)

  1. Cinnamon sugar rounds. Use the dough above and roll the balls in cinnamon sugar instead of sprinkles. Cozy and quick.
  2. Chocolate chip cookies with red and green candies. Your usual chocolate chip dough, with festive candy pressed on top before baking. See how long to bake chocolate chip cookies for times by size.
  3. Cake mix cookies. A box of cake mix, oil and eggs. Add sprinkles and you're done. Here's how to turn cake mix into cookies.
  4. Monster cookies. Peanut butter, oats and candy, with no flour at all. Try our monster cookies with red and green candies for Christmas.
  5. Molasses cookies. Soft, chewy and rolled in sugar. Our molasses cookies recipe smells like Christmas.
  6. Hot chocolate cookies. Fudgy cocoa cookies with a marshmallow on top. Kids love these hot chocolate cookies.
  7. Sandwich cookies. Bake the sprinkle rounds, then sandwich two with a spoonful of frosting or jam.
Baking guideHow Long to Bake Chocolate Chip Cookies: Times by SizeTake a look → Baking guideConvert Cake Mix to Cookies, Muffins and Brownies: RatiosFind my pan size →

Easy (one short chill or one simple tool)

  1. Shortbread. Just five ingredients: butter, sugar, flour, salt and vanilla. Our shortbread cookies recipe is buttery and crisp.
  2. Snowball cookies. Little buttery balls rolled in powdered sugar. Our snowball cookies without nuts are great for nut-free tins.
  3. Chocolate crinkle cookies. Rolled in powdered sugar so they crack like snowy ground. Here's our chocolate crinkle cookies recipe.
  4. Spritz cookies. Press them out with a cookie press, no chilling needed. Our spritz cookies recipe makes lots fast.
  5. Red velvet cookies. Soft, chewy and very Christmas-red. Try our red velvet cookies.
  6. Chocolate-dipped rounds. Dip half of each plain round in melted chocolate, then into sprinkles. Here's how to melt chocolate without it seizing.
  7. Christmas tree slice-and-bakes. Tint the dough above green with gel color, roll it into a log, roll the log in sprinkles, chill and slice.
Baking guideShortbread Cookies Recipe: Buttery, Crisp, 5 IngredientsRead the guide → Baking guideSnowball Cookies Without Nuts: What to Use InsteadGet the swap chart →

A little more effort (and worth it)

  1. Sugar cookie cut-outs. Stars, trees and stockings that hold their shape. Our sugar cookie recipe is made for cutters.
  2. Gingerbread men. Soft, spiced and easy to cut. Start with our gingerbread men recipe.
  3. Butter cookies. Piped rings and rosettes, like the ones in a holiday tin. See our butter cookies recipe.
  4. Candy cane twists. Tint half of a batch of the dough above red, roll thin ropes of red and plain, twist them together and bend the top into a hook.
  5. Meringue cookies. Crisp and airy, baked in a low oven. Our meringue cookies recipe is naturally gluten-free.
  6. Italian Christmas cookies. Soft ricotta cookies with a sweet glaze, and 16 more. See our Italian Christmas cookies.
Baking guideSugar Cookie Recipe for Cut-Outs That Hold Their ShapeRead it next → Baking guideGingerbread Men Recipe: Soft, Spiced and Easy to CutLearn more →

Looking for pies, fudge and cakes too? Our Christmas desserts list has 28 holiday favorites.

Baking guideChristmas Desserts: 28 Easy Holiday Favorites to BakeGet the details →

Which easy Christmas cookies are best for beginners?

CookieChill needed?Special tool?Freezes well?
Sprinkle rounds (this page)NoNoYes
Jam thumbprints (this page)NoNoBest frozen unfilled, or as dough
Pinwheels (this page)30 minNoYes, as a log or baked
ShortbreadShortNoYes
Chocolate crinklesYesNoYes, as dough balls
SpritzNoCookie pressYes
Sugar cookie cut-outsYesRolling pin and cuttersYes, undecorated
Meringue cookiesNoMixerNot ideal (they soften)

Can I make these Christmas cookies ahead?

Yes, and it's the secret to a calm December.

Baking guideHow to Freeze Cookie Dough: Flash Freeze, Then Bag ItRead the dough guide → Baking guideChristmas Cookies That Freeze Well and How to Do ItSee how long it keeps →

Common mistakes with easy Christmas cookies

Packing easy Christmas cookies for gifts

A mix of all three looks lovely in a tin: the round sprinkles, the shiny red jam and the swirled pinwheels. Put the thumbprints in a single layer on top so the jam doesn't stick to anything, and slip parchment between layers. Baking for the whole street? Our cookie tin planner works out how many of each kind you need.

Questions people ask

What are the easiest Christmas cookies to make?

Simple butter cookie rounds rolled in sprinkles, jam thumbprints, shortbread and cake mix cookies are about as easy as it gets. None of them need a rolling pin or cookie cutters, and most don't need chilling.

What Christmas cookies are good for beginners?

Start with drop or rolled-ball cookies like sprinkle rounds, thumbprints, snowball cookies or chocolate crinkles. Save cut-outs and decorated cookies for when you feel comfortable, since they need rolling, chilling and icing.

Are there 5-ingredient Christmas cookies?

Yes. Classic shortbread needs only butter, sugar, flour, salt and vanilla. Cake mix cookies need just a box of cake mix, oil, eggs and sprinkles.

How far ahead can I make Christmas cookies?

Most butter cookies keep about a week in an airtight tin. For longer, freeze the dough for up to 3 months, or freeze baked cookies and thaw them in the container so they don't get soggy.

Why did my thumbprint cookies crack?

The dough was a little dry or cold when you pressed the well. Let it warm up for a few minutes, and if it still cracks, roll the ball smooth again and press more gently. A few small cracks are normal and get hidden by the jam.

Can I make these cookies without eggs?

Usually, yes. In this dough, 3 tablespoons of milk or plain yogurt in place of the egg works well. The cookies will be a little more tender and crumbly.