Cookie Tins for 12 Neighbors: How Many of Each Kind to Bake
Plan 12 cookies per tin, multiply by the number of tins, add 10 percent for breakage and taste tests, then split that total evenly across your flavors: for 12 neighbors that's about 160 cookies, or 40 of each of 4 kinds. Once you know each flavor's share, scale every recipe to hit that number instead of baking one batch of each and hoping it works out.
The free recipe converter does the scaling part for you. You tell it how many cookies a recipe makes and how many you actually need, and it rebuilds every ingredient line in real kitchen measures, so you're not standing at the counter trying to work out 1.67 times three quarters of a cup.
Most gift bakers don't run short on cookies overall. They run short on one kind. The chocolate crinkles make 30 instead of 48, the spritz recipe turns out to be a half batch, and by tin number nine there are no more stars. This guide walks through the numbers so every tin gets the same mix.
The Quick Math: Cookies per Tin and per Flavor
Here's the whole method in four steps. Write the numbers down before you buy a single bag of flour.
- Pick cookies per tin. For an average gift tin (roughly 7 inches across), 12 cookies is a generous, full-looking amount. Small tins take 8 to 10. Big tins take 16 or more.
- Multiply by the number of tins. 12 tins x 12 cookies = 144 cookies.
- Add a 10 percent buffer. 144 x 1.1 = 158.4. Round up to a number that divides cleanly by your flavor count, so 160.
- Divide by the number of flavors. 160 / 4 flavors = 40 cookies of each kind.
That last number is the one that matters. Every recipe you bake has a single job: make 40 good cookies. If a recipe makes 24, you need roughly 1.7 batches. If it makes 48, one batch is plenty and you have a few extra for the house.
Why 10 percent?
A buffer covers the cookies that crack when you lift them off the sheet, the ones that spread into their neighbors, the ones that brown too much on the back row, and the two or three that disappear while they cool. Ten percent is a sensible starting point for sturdy cookies like shortbread or sugar cookies. For fragile ones, such as thin lace cookies, snowballs that crumble, or anything with a delicate piped edge, bump that flavor's buffer to 15 or 20 percent.
The quick reference chart
This table assumes 12 cookies per tin and a 10 percent buffer, rounded up so the total divides evenly by the number of flavors.
| Tins | Cookies in the tins | Bake (with buffer) | 3 flavors | 4 flavors | 5 flavors |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 4 | 48 | 54 | 18 each | 14 each | 11 each |
| 6 | 72 | 80 | 27 each | 20 each | 16 each |
| 8 | 96 | 106 | 36 each | 27 each | 22 each |
| 10 | 120 | 132 | 44 each | 33 each | 27 each |
| 12 | 144 | 160 | 54 each | 40 each | 32 each |
| 15 | 180 | 198 | 66 each | 50 each | 40 each |
| 20 | 240 | 264 | 88 each | 66 each | 53 each |
Each flavor share is rounded up, so the flavors can add up to a few more than the bake column. That's fine, since a couple of spares never hurt. If you use a different count per tin, just swap the second column. For 10 cookies per tin, 12 tins is 120 cookies, plus 10 percent is 132, which splits into 33 of each across 4 flavors.
How Many Cookies Actually Fit in a Tin
"12 per tin" is a planning number, not a law. The real number depends on the tin and the cookie. A cookie that looks small on the sheet can take up a surprising amount of room once you add parchment between layers and leave space so the top layer doesn't get crushed by the lid.
The easiest way to know for sure is a dry run. Before you bake for real, take one empty tin and lay out cookies (or cookie-sized paper circles) the size you plan to bake. Count how many fit in a single layer, then decide how many layers you're willing to stack. Most cookies handle two or three layers with parchment between them. Iced or decorated cookies usually go in one or two layers only.
Here are rough working figures for round tins about 2 to 3 inches deep, using cookies about 2 to 2.5 inches across.
| Tin size (across the top) | Cookies per layer | Layers that work | Planning number |
|---|---|---|---|
| About 5 to 6 inches | 4 to 5 | 2 | 8 to 10 |
| About 7 inches | 6 to 7 | 2 | 12 to 14 |
| About 8 inches | 8 to 9 | 2 to 3 | 16 to 20 |
| About 9 to 10 inches | 11 to 13 | 2 to 3 | 22 to 30 |
| Long rectangular tin (about 9 x 4 inches) | Stand cookies on edge in rows | 1 row deep | 14 to 18 |
Tins vary a lot between makers, so treat this as a starting point and trust your dry run over the chart. Also notice that standing cookies on their edge, like books on a shelf, often fits more in a deep tin than stacking flat. It works best for sturdy round cookies such as shortbread rounds, crinkles and sandwich cookies.
Cookie size changes everything
Big cookies make a tin look full fast. Small ones let you fit more flavors. If you want five or six kinds in each tin, make every cookie on the smaller side, around 1.5 to 2 inches, so you can include two or three of each kind without the tin overflowing.
| Cookie size | Typical scoop or cutter | Cookies in a 7-inch tin | Good for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bite size, about 1.5 inches | 2-teaspoon scoop or small cutter | 16 to 20 | Many flavors per tin |
| Standard, about 2 to 2.5 inches | 1-tablespoon scoop or 2-inch cutter | 12 to 14 | Most gift tins |
| Large, about 3 to 3.5 inches | 2-tablespoon scoop or 3-inch cutter | 6 to 8 | Fewer kinds, bakery look |
Here's the catch: changing cookie size changes your recipe's yield. A recipe that says "makes 36" assumes the scoop size the recipe writer used. If you switch to a smaller scoop, you'll get more cookies. If you switch to a bigger cutter, you'll get fewer. When in doubt, bake a test sheet and count. A recipe that makes 36 with a 1-tablespoon scoop makes roughly 18 with a 2-tablespoon scoop and about 50 to 54 with a 2-teaspoon scoop.
Choosing Your Flavors and How Many of Each
A good gift tin has contrast. Think about color, texture and shape more than just taste. A tin with four brown drop cookies looks plain, even if they're all delicious. A tin with a pale cut-out, a dark chocolate cookie, a round sugared ball and something striped or swirled looks like it came from a bakery.
A balanced four-flavor tin
- One cut-out cookie for shape: sugar cookies or gingerbread in stars, trees or mittens.
- One chocolate cookie for color: crinkles, chocolate shortbread or a fudgy drop cookie.
- One sturdy, buttery cookie for keeping: shortbread, spritz or snowballs.
- One "wow" cookie that's a little special: thumbprints, pinwheels, or a sandwich cookie.
If you're new to big gift batches, our sugar cookie recipe is a reliable base for the cut-out slot. It holds its shape, it freezes well as dough, and it takes icing nicely.
Equal shares or weighted shares?
Equal shares are the simplest: 40 of each kind for 12 tins. But sometimes you want a weighted mix. Maybe the star cookies are the showpiece and you want four in every tin, while the thumbprints are fiddly and two each is plenty.
Here's how to plan a weighted tin for 12 neighbors at 12 cookies per tin:
| Flavor | Per tin | x 12 tins | Buffer | Bake |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Iced sugar cookie stars | 4 | 48 | 15 percent (icing breaks) | 56 |
| Chocolate crinkles | 3 | 36 | 10 percent | 40 |
| Shortbread rounds | 3 | 36 | 10 percent | 40 |
| Jam thumbprints | 2 | 24 | 15 percent (fragile) | 28 |
| Total | 12 | 144 | 164 |
Notice that the per-tin numbers add to exactly 12, and each flavor gets its own buffer based on how fragile it is. That's the real fix for running short on one kind: plan per flavor, not just in total.
How shelf life affects your flavor choice
Cookies in a gift tin often sit on a neighbor's counter for a week or more. Mixing a long-keeping cookie with a short-keeping one in the same tin means one of them goes stale first and can make the other soft. Our guide to how long Christmas cookies last has the full chart, but in short:
- Keep well (up to about 2 weeks airtight): shortbread, gingerbread, iced sugar cookies, snowballs, spritz.
- Shorter window (about 3 to 5 days): soft chocolate chip, jam thumbprints.
- Fridge only: anything with buttercream or cream cheese frosting. Leave these out of gift tins.
If you're giving tins over a few days, pick mostly long-keeping cookies so the last neighbor gets the same quality as the first.
How to Do It with the Free Recipe Converter
Once you know each flavor's target, you need every recipe to produce that many cookies. That's where people usually guess, and guessing is how you end up with 22 crinkles when you needed 40. The free recipe converter turns your target into a full scaled ingredient list.
Here's the exact walkthrough for one flavor. Repeat it for each recipe.
Step 1: Find the recipe's real yield
Look at what the recipe says it makes, for example "makes about 30 cookies." If you've baked it before and know your scoop gives a different count, use your own number. Your count beats the recipe's every time.
Step 2: Paste the ingredients
Copy the ingredient list into the box labeled 1. Paste or type your ingredients, one per line. Keep each ingredient on its own line, just as it appears in the recipe. The converter reads amounts like 1 1/2 cups, 3/4 cup, 2 tbsp, 1 stick butter, 250 g and 3 large eggs. Lines without a number, such as a heading or "salt to taste," pass through unchanged, so your scaled list still reads like a recipe.
Step 3: Set the yield boxes
Under 2. Pick a size, skip the preset buttons for a moment and go to the two boxes below them:
- In Recipe serves, type the recipe's yield in cookies, for example 30.
- In You want, type your target for that flavor, for example 40.
- Click Use this.
The converter just divides one number by the other, so "serves" can mean cookies here. It works out the multiplier for you, in this case 40 / 30 = 1.33, and rescales every line.
Step 4: Check the result and round sensibly
The scaled list shows each amount in measures you can actually scoop: whole cups, standard cup fractions, tablespoons and teaspoons. When an exact answer falls between two real measures, it's marked about, with the true figure shown underneath. For flour, sugar and butter, the rounded version is fine. For baking soda and baking powder, take a second look at the flag.
The one thing you'll have to decide yourself is eggs. Multiplying 2 eggs by 1.33 gives 2.67 eggs, and no carton sells those. You have two good choices:
- Round the whole batch to a cleaner multiplier. Click the 1½× Half again button instead. Two eggs become three, and 30 cookies become 45. You'll have five extras, which go straight into the buffer.
- Use beaten egg by weight. A large egg is about 50 grams out of the shell. Beat the eggs together and weigh out what you need. The converter's notes explain how to do this for half an egg.
For most cookie baking, rounding to the nearest preset button (⅓, ½, ⅔, 1½×, 2× or 3×) is the easiest path. A few extra cookies cost you nothing, and you avoid fractional eggs completely.
Step 5: Copy or print
Click Copy the scaled list to paste it into your notes, or Print to tape it above the mixer. When you're baking four recipes in one weekend, a printed scaled list for each one stops you from adding the original amounts halfway through by habit.
When to make the recipe twice instead of tripling
If a flavor needs three times its recipe, the converter has a 3× Triple button, but its own guidance says that above double, it's safer to make the recipe twice than once at 3x. Home mixers struggle with huge cookie doughs, and leaveners and salt can taste off when scaled straight up. For a cookie that needs 2.6 batches, a practical plan is two separate batches mixed one after the other: a double and a single, or a double and a ⅔.
Worked Examples for Different Gift Lists
The numbers get clearer when you see them for real recipes. Here are four common situations, worked all the way through.
Example 1: 12 neighbors, 4 flavors, 12 cookies per tin
Target: 160 cookies, 40 of each.
| Flavor | Recipe yield | Target | Raw multiplier | Button to use | You'll get |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sugar cookie cut-outs | 24 | 40 | 1.67 | 1½× gives only 36, so 2× | 48 |
| Chocolate crinkles | 36 | 40 | 1.11 | Recipe as written, with a slightly smaller scoop | 40 to 42 |
| Shortbread rounds | 30 | 40 | 1.33 | 1½× | 45 |
| Spritz | 60 | 40 | 0.67 | ⅔ Two thirds | 40 |
The crinkles are the trickiest. At 1.11x, you can type the exact numbers (Recipe serves 36, You want 40) and live with some "about" measures, or make the recipe as written and use a slightly smaller scoop to stretch it to 40. A scoop that's a little smaller than the recipe's gives you more cookies without any math, and nobody notices a slightly smaller crinkle in a mixed tin.
Total baked: about 173 to 175. That's more than 160, which means a generous buffer and a plate for your own house.
Example 2: 6 tins for close neighbors, 3 flavors, small tins
You picked up small 6-inch tins, and your dry run says 9 cookies fit nicely. Three flavors, three of each per tin.
- Cookies in tins: 6 x 9 = 54
- With 10 percent: 59.4, rounded to 60
- Per flavor: 20
A recipe that makes 36 needs the ½ Half button (18 cookies, a little short) or ⅔ Two thirds (24 cookies, safe). Go with ⅔. You'll get 72 cookies in total, enough for the tins and a few spares. Small gift lists are the one time small batches really shine, because many standard recipes make far more than you need.
Example 3: 20 tins for a whole street, 5 flavors
This is the big one. At 12 per tin:
- Cookies in tins: 240
- With 10 percent: 264
- Per flavor: 53 (a recipe that makes 27, doubled, lands at 54)
Here's where people overestimate their oven. 264 cookies at about 12 per sheet is 22 sheets. If you can bake two sheets at a time and each round takes about 12 minutes plus a few minutes to swap pans, that's roughly 2.5 to 3 hours of oven time, not counting cooling and decorating. Split it across two or three baking days and freeze dough ahead (see the timeline below).
Example 4: Mixed tin sizes
Sometimes you have a few big tins for close friends and smaller ones for everyone else. Work each group separately, then add them up.
| Group | Tins | Cookies per tin | Cookies |
|---|---|---|---|
| Close neighbors (8-inch tins) | 4 | 18 | 72 |
| Street neighbors (6-inch tins) | 10 | 9 | 90 |
| Mail carrier, teacher, coach (bags) | 3 | 6 | 18 |
| Subtotal | 180 | ||
| Plus 10 percent | 198 |
With 4 flavors, that's about 50 of each. If you want each small tin to hold 2 of each flavor plus one bonus cookie, plan the flavor counts per tin first, then multiply. Planning per tin always beats planning per batch.
A December Baking Timeline for Gift Tins
The big mistake isn't the math. It's trying to do everything on one weekend. Spreading the work out keeps the quality up and the kitchen calm. Here's a timeline that works for most gift lists. Count backward from the day you plan to deliver.
| When | What to do |
|---|---|
| 4 weeks before delivery | Count your tins and do the dry run. Pick flavors. Work out per-flavor targets. |
| 3 to 4 weeks before | Scale each recipe with the converter. Print the scaled lists. Make one combined shopping list. |
| 3 weeks before | Mix and freeze doughs that freeze well: shortbread, sugar cookie dough, gingerbread, drop cookie dough scooped into balls. |
| 1 to 2 weeks before | Bake sturdy, long-keeping cookies. Cool fully and store airtight, or freeze the baked cookies. |
| 3 to 5 days before | Bake shorter-keeping cookies such as thumbprints and soft drop cookies. Ice cut-outs and let the icing dry fully. |
| 1 to 2 days before | Thaw anything frozen in its sealed container. Pack the tins. |
| Delivery day | Add tags and deliver. |
Our guide to Christmas cookies that freeze well lists which cookies are happiest made weeks ahead, and how to freeze cookie dough walks through scooping, wrapping and baking straight from frozen.
Build one shopping list from the scaled recipes
Once every recipe is scaled, add up the big ingredients across all of them before you shop. Four cookie recipes that each use a little butter can quietly add up to far more than you'd guess. Here's what a typical four-flavor plan for 12 tins might look like once the scaled lists are combined:
| Ingredient | Sugar cookies (2×) | Crinkles (1×) | Shortbread (1½×) | Spritz (⅔) | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Butter | 2 cups | 1/2 cup | 1 1/2 cups | 2/3 cup | About 4 2/3 cups |
| All-purpose flour | 6 cups | 2 cups | 3 cups | 1 2/3 cups | About 12 2/3 cups |
| Granulated sugar | 2 cups | 1 1/2 cups | 3/4 cup | 1/2 cup | About 4 3/4 cups |
| Large eggs | 2 | 2 | 0 | 1 | 5 |
Your recipes will have their own amounts, so treat this as a pattern rather than a shopping list to copy. The point is to total each ingredient across every scaled list, then add about 10 percent for rerolled scraps, a spilled cup of flour or a test sheet. Butter and eggs are the two that run out most often, so check those twice. If your recipes give butter in sticks, remember that 1 cup is 2 sticks.
Why freezing dough helps the count
Frozen dough balls let you bake exactly what you need. If you find you're 8 crinkles short after packing, pull 8 balls from the freezer and bake one small sheet. That's much easier than mixing a whole new batch on packing day.
Leave time for icing to dry
If you're decorating cut-outs with royal icing, the flooded tops need many hours to dry hard before you stack them. Plan to ice them at least a day before packing. Stacking soft icing is one of the most common ways to lose a whole flavor at the last minute, because every cookie in the stack gets dented.
Thaw before you open
When you take frozen cookies out to pack, leave them in their sealed container or bag until they reach room temperature. If you open a cold container right away, moisture from the air condenses on the cookies and can make crisp ones soft and icing tacky.
Packing the Tins So Every One Looks the Same
Packing day is where your planning pays off. Set up an assembly line so every tin gets the same mix and you can see right away if one flavor is running low.
Set up the line
- Line up every open tin on the table with a square of parchment or a paper liner in the bottom.
- Put each flavor on its own tray in the order it goes into the tins: sturdiest and heaviest first, most delicate last.
- Count out one flavor at a time across all tins. Drop 3 shortbread rounds into every tin, then 3 crinkles into every tin, and so on. Don't fill one tin completely before starting the next. Going flavor by flavor shows you a shortage while you can still fix it.
- Add a parchment layer between layers so icing and sugar coatings don't rub off on the cookies above.
- Put the prettiest cookies on top. The cut-outs or the special cookie should be the first thing your neighbor sees when the lid comes off.
Keep soft and crisp cookies apart
In a shared tin, crisp cookies pull moisture from soft ones, and both end up in a so-so middle texture. If your mix includes a soft cookie, wrap that flavor in its own small bag or a twist of wax paper before it goes into the tin. Strongly flavored cookies, such as peppermint or spiced gingerbread, can also flavor their neighbors over a few days. A small bag solves that too.
Pad the empty space
A half-empty tin lets cookies slide around and break on the walk next door. If you have a gap, tuck in a crumpled piece of parchment or a folded paper liner. Don't fill gaps with loose candy; it shifts and chips icing.
A packing checklist
- All cookies completely cool (warm cookies steam inside a closed tin)
- Icing dry to the touch and firm when pressed lightly at the edge
- Parchment between every layer
- Soft and strongly flavored cookies wrapped separately
- Top layer at least a little below the rim so the lid doesn't press it
- Tag with what's inside and a note about common allergens, such as nuts, wheat, eggs and milk
That last point matters more than people think. A simple ingredients tag lets a neighbor with an allergy, or a parent of a child with one, decide quickly what's safe. "Contains nuts: thumbprints" is all it takes.
Troubleshooting: When the Count Goes Wrong
Even with a plan, things go sideways. Here's how to fix the common problems without starting over.
| Problem | Likely cause | Fix |
|---|---|---|
| One flavor came up short | Recipe yield was optimistic, or scoop was bigger than the recipe's | Bake a small top-up batch with the ⅓ or ½ button, or give that flavor 2 per tin and add 1 extra of a plentiful flavor |
| Far too many of one flavor | Recipe made more than stated, or you used a smaller scoop | Keep the spares for your own house or a second round of gifts. Next year, scale down with the ⅔ or ½ button. |
| Cookies spread and won't fit the tin | Dough too warm, or a smaller pan of cookies baked longer | Chill the remaining dough before baking. For tins, cookies can stand on edge if they're sturdy. |
| Iced cookies smudged when stacked | Icing wasn't fully dry | Pack iced cookies in a single top layer, or wait another day before packing |
| Tins look sparse | Planned too few per tin, or cookies too small | Add a layer of the most plentiful flavor, or shrink the tin count by one and spread the extras |
| Crisp cookies went soft in the tin | Packed with soft cookies, or packed warm | Wrap soft cookies separately; cool everything fully before closing the lid |
| Ran out of a key ingredient mid-batch | Shopping list was made from original recipes, not scaled ones | Make your shopping list from the scaled lists, then add 10 percent for spills and rerolls |
| Scaled dough tastes salty or soapy | Leaveners and salt scaled past 2x | Make the recipe twice at 1x or 1½x instead of once at 3x |
The shortage swap
If you're short on one flavor and don't have time to bake, rework the per-tin plan. Say your thumbprints came up 8 short for 12 tins at 3 each. You have 28 thumbprints. Give 4 tins 3 thumbprints (12 cookies) and 8 tins 2 thumbprints (16 cookies). That's 28 exactly. Fill the 8 shorter tins with one extra of your most plentiful flavor. Everyone still gets 12 cookies, and nobody's tin looks shortchanged.
Variations by Gift List and Household
Not every tin needs to be identical. The size of the household on the other end matters, and a couple of small tweaks make the gift feel thoughtful instead of one-size-fits-all.
By household size
| Household | Suggested cookies | Why |
|---|---|---|
| One person living alone | 6 to 8 | Fewer cookies stay fresh before they're eaten |
| Couple | 10 to 12 | The standard tin |
| Family with kids | 14 to 18 | Kids eat cookies fast, and siblings like having their own |
| Big family or multi-generation home | 18 to 24 | A large tin or two smaller ones |
| Office or break room | 24 to 36 | A platter or large tin, mostly sturdy cookies |
If you plan this way, write your list as names with a target count beside each one, then total it. That total plus 10 percent is your bake number. It's a little more work up front but avoids handing a single neighbor 18 cookies they can't finish while the family of six gets 12.
Baking with kids
Kids love gift baking, and it's a great way to spend a December weekend. A few tips for keeping the count on track:
- Give kids the jobs that don't change the yield: rolling dough balls in sugar, pressing thumbprints, adding sprinkles, packing tins.
- Plan an extra 10 percent on top of your buffer for any flavor the kids decorate. Some cookies will be "too pretty to give away."
- Let each child build one special tin with their own favorite arrangement. It's a nice way to give them ownership, and it's one tin you don't need to make identical.
Dietary needs
If a neighbor needs a gluten-free, egg-free or nut-free tin, bake that tin's cookies separately, pack it first on a freshly cleaned counter, and label it clearly. Don't just pull those flavors out of your regular mix, since crumbs and shared trays can carry over. Count these tins separately in your plan so they don't eat into the main totals.
What to write on the tag
A short note makes a tin of cookies feel personal, and it gives your neighbor practical information. Here are a few scripts you can copy.
Simple and warm: "Merry Christmas from the house at the corner! Inside: shortbread, chocolate crinkles, sugar cookie stars and jam thumbprints. Best within a week. Contains wheat, eggs and milk."
For a neighbor you don't know well: "Hi! We're your neighbors at number 14 and wanted to say happy holidays. These are homemade. The thumbprints contain almonds; the rest are nut-free. Enjoy!"
For a family with kids: "For the whole crew! The stars were decorated by our kids, so every one is one of a kind. Keep the lid on tight and they'll stay fresh for about a week."
Keep it short. A tag with flavors, a freshness window and allergens is more useful than a long letter, and it keeps you from writing 20 different notes by hand on packing night.
Plan the numbers once, bake with confidence
Running short on one flavor is a planning problem, not a baking problem. Decide how many cookies go in each tin, multiply by your tins, add 10 percent, and split it across flavors. Then give each recipe one clear job: produce its share.
When you're ready to turn those shares into shopping lists and mixing bowls, open the free recipe converter, type the recipe's yield and your target, and print the scaled list for each flavor. Twenty minutes of math in November saves a frantic extra batch on December 23rd.
Frequently Asked Questions
How many cookies per cookie tin is normal?
For an average gift tin about 7 inches across, 12 cookies of 2 to 2.5 inches is a full, generous tin. Small 5- to 6-inch tins hold about 8 to 10, and large 8-inch tins hold 16 to 20 in two or three layers. Do a quick dry run with your actual tin to be sure.
How many different kinds of cookies should go in a gift tin?
Three to five kinds is the sweet spot. Fewer than three looks plain, and more than five usually means only one or two of each, which can look scattered unless the cookies are small. Four kinds with three of each is an easy, balanced tin.
How much extra should I bake for breakage?
Plan 10 percent extra for sturdy cookies like shortbread, sugar cookies and crinkles. For fragile cookies, such as thumbprints, lacy cookies or anything with delicate icing, plan 15 to 20 percent extra for that flavor alone. It's always easier to have a few spares than to bake one more batch on packing day.
How do I scale a cookie recipe to make exactly the number I need?
Paste the ingredients into the recipe converter, type the recipe's yield in the "Recipe serves" box and your target in the "You want" box, then click "Use this." If that gives odd amounts like 2.67 eggs, round to the nearest preset button, such as 1½× or 2×, and treat the extra cookies as part of your buffer.
How far ahead can I bake cookies for gift tins?
Sturdy, buttery cookies like shortbread, gingerbread and iced sugar cookies keep up to about 2 weeks in an airtight container. Soft cookies and jam thumbprints are best within about 5 days. For anything longer, freeze the dough or the baked cookies and thaw them in their sealed container before packing.
Can I put soft and crisp cookies in the same tin?
You can, but wrap the soft ones in their own small bag first. Otherwise the crisp cookies absorb moisture from the soft ones and both end up with a so-so texture. Strongly flavored cookies, like peppermint, also do better wrapped separately.
How many cookies do I need for 12 tins?
At 12 cookies per tin, you need 144 for the tins plus about 10 percent extra, so plan 160. Split across 4 flavors, that's 40 of each kind. If your tins are small and hold 8 to 10, plan about 110 to 132 instead.
Should I triple a cookie recipe or make it three times?
Make it in separate batches if you need more than double. Very large doughs are hard to mix evenly in a home mixer, and leaveners and salt can taste stronger when scaled straight up. A double batch followed by a single batch gives better, more even cookies than one triple batch.
