Christmas Desserts: 28 Easy Holiday Favorites
The best Christmas desserts are the ones that feel like the holidays and don't wreck your week: a plate of cookies (sugar cookies, gingerbread men, chocolate crinkles), a pan of fudge or peppermint bark, and one or two pies like pecan, pumpkin or apple. Below are 28 easy favorites, grouped by type, with a note on which ones you can make ahead, freeze or give as gifts.
Christmas falls on a Friday this year, so you've got the whole weekend before to bake. Pick two or three from different groups, one cookie, one candy and one pie, and your dessert table is done.
Christmas cookies
Cookies are the heart of holiday baking. They're easy to share, they freeze well, and most doughs can be made weeks ahead.
- Cut-out sugar cookies. The classic for decorating. This dough holds its shape, so your stars still look like stars.
- Gingerbread men. Warmly spiced and so fun to decorate with kids. Bake them a little longer if you want them crisp enough to hang on the tree.
- Chocolate crinkle cookies. Fudgy chocolate cookies rolled in powdered sugar that crack into a snowy pattern as they bake. Easy and very pretty.
- Spritz cookies. Little buttery shapes pressed out of a cookie press. You can bake a big batch fast, and they keep for days.
- Shortbread cookies. Just butter, sugar and flour, and somehow perfect. One of the best keepers for cookie tins.
- Molasses cookies. Soft, chewy and spiced, with a sugary crackle on top. They stay soft for days.
- Butter cookies. Simple, crisp and buttery, and one of the best cookies for gifting.
- Meringue cookies. Light, crisp and naturally gluten free. Swirl in a little red food coloring and peppermint for candy cane kisses.
- Hot chocolate cookies. Rich chocolate cookies that taste like a mug of cocoa. Kids go wild for these.
- Red velvet cookies. Soft, festive red cookies that look gorgeous on a platter next to anything white or green.
- Snowball cookies (nut-free option). Melt-in-your-mouth balls rolled in powdered sugar. This version swaps out the nuts, so it's safe for more of your guests.
- Monster cookies. Oats, peanut butter, chocolate chips and candy-coated chocolates. Use red and green candies and they're instantly Christmas cookies.
Baking a lot of these at once? This planner shows how long 10 dozen cookies take in the oven, and this guide covers which Christmas cookies freeze well.
Christmas pies
One or two pies make any dinner feel special. Most of them can be baked a day ahead, which frees up your oven for the main meal.
- Pecan pie. Gooey, toasty and rich. A small slice goes a long way, so one pie feeds a crowd.
- Pumpkin pie. Not just for Thanksgiving. A silky, spiced custard that's even better made the day before.
- Apple pie. Flaky double crust and a thick, sliceable filling. Serve it warm with a scoop of vanilla ice cream.
- Dutch apple pie. Apple pie with a crunchy brown sugar crumb topping instead of a top crust. Only one crust to roll, so it's a great first pie.
- Chess pie. An old Southern favorite: a sweet, buttery custard with a crackly top, made almost entirely from pantry staples.
- Buttermilk pie. Creamy, tangy and a little like cheesecake. It's even better after a night in the fridge.
Not sure how many to bake? Here's how many pies you need for Christmas dinner, by number of guests.
Christmas candy and no-bake treats
Candy is the secret weapon of holiday baking. Most of it needs no oven, keeps for weeks and looks great in a gift tin.
- Fudge. Rich, creamy and made on the stovetop. Cut it into small squares, since it's very sweet.
- Peppermint bark. Layers of chocolate topped with crushed candy canes. No oven needed, about 35 minutes of hands-on time, and maybe the easiest gift you can make.
- Saltine toffee. Buttery toffee poured over saltine crackers and baked until bubbly. Salty, sweet and very hard to stop eating.
- Chocolate truffles. Just chocolate and cream rolled into balls, then dusted in cocoa or sprinkles. The ganache guide gives you the right ratio for truffles.
- Homemade soft caramels. Chewy, buttery caramels wrapped in wax paper make an old-fashioned gift. A candy thermometer makes them easy.
Packing candy into tins? This chart shows how much fudge or peppermint bark fits in a gift tin.
Christmas cakes, rolls and showstoppers
When you want one dessert that people will remember (and maybe photograph), go for one of these.
- Pumpkin roll. A soft spiced pumpkin cake rolled around cream cheese filling. It looks fancy, slices beautifully and freezes well.
- Christmas pudding. The rich, fruity, steamed British classic. Make it early so the flavors have time to mellow.
- Mini fruitcakes. Little loaves packed with fruit, perfect for gifting. Not a fan of nuts? Here's fruitcake without nuts.
- Christmas morning cinnamon rolls. Soft, gooey rolls for breakfast on the big day. No 9x13 pan? Two round pans or a skillet work fine.
- A homemade gingerbread house. More of a project than a dessert, but it's the best kind of holiday afternoon. This guide helps you plan the panel sizes.
Which Christmas desserts can you make ahead?
Here's the honest truth: the calmest holiday bakers do most of it early. This chart shows how far ahead each kind of treat can be made.
| Dessert | Make ahead (room temp or fridge) | Freezer |
|---|---|---|
| Shortbread, butter cookies, spritz | 1 to 2 weeks in a tin | Up to 3 months |
| Molasses, gingerbread and sugar cookies | About 1 week in a tin | Up to 3 months, baked or as dough |
| Chocolate crinkle and red velvet cookies | 3 to 5 days | Up to 3 months as dough |
| Meringue cookies | Up to 2 weeks, airtight and dry | Not recommended |
| Fudge and peppermint bark | 1 to 2 weeks (bark in a cool spot) | Up to 3 months |
| Pecan, apple and Dutch apple pie | 1 to 2 days | Up to 3 months |
| Pumpkin, chess and buttermilk pie | 1 to 2 days in the fridge | Up to 2 months |
| Pumpkin roll | 2 to 3 days in the fridge | Up to 3 months |
| Fruitcake and Christmas pudding | Weeks, well wrapped | Up to 1 year |
For cookie storage by type, this guide covers how long Christmas cookies last on the counter, in the fridge and in the freezer.
A simple Christmas baking plan
You don't need to bake everything in one weekend. Spread it out like this:
- Early December: Make the fruitcakes or Christmas pudding, and mix and freeze cookie doughs.
- About 2 weeks before: Bake the sturdy cookies (shortbread, spritz, butter cookies) and store them in tins.
- The week before: Make fudge, peppermint bark and toffee for gifts, and bake the soft cookies.
- 1 to 2 days before: Bake the pies and the pumpkin roll.
- Christmas Eve: Assemble the cinnamon rolls and let them rise slowly in the fridge overnight.
Easy Christmas desserts for gifting
The best gift treats are sturdy, keep well and don't need a fridge. Fudge, peppermint bark, saltine toffee, shortbread, spritz, butter cookies, molasses cookies and mini fruitcakes all fit the bill. Line tins with parchment, keep crisp cookies away from soft ones (soft cookies make crisp ones go limp), and add a little tag with the name of each treat. Giving to the whole street? This guide shows how many of each cookie to bake for 12 neighbor tins.
Common Christmas baking mistakes
- Baking everything the day before. Most cookies and candy keep for a week or more. Start early and save the last days for pies.
- Storing all your cookies in one tin. Soft cookies make crisp ones soggy, and peppermint flavors everything near it. Use separate containers.
- Cutting pies while warm. Fruit and custard pies need hours to set. Bake them a day ahead and you'll get clean slices.
- Making only rich desserts. Pair something heavy like pecan pie with something lighter like meringue cookies or apple pie, so everyone finds something they want.
- Forgetting the nut-free guests. Snowball cookies without nuts, sugar cookies, and fruitcake without nuts mean nobody misses out.
More free baking tools
Questions people ask
What are the most popular Christmas desserts?
The classics are cut-out sugar cookies, gingerbread men, fudge, peppermint bark, pecan pie, pumpkin pie and pumpkin roll. Chocolate crinkle cookies and shortbread are close behind. A cookie plate plus one pie covers most family gatherings.
What Christmas desserts can I make ahead?
Fudge, peppermint bark, shortbread, butter cookies and molasses cookies all keep 1 to 2 weeks in a tin. Most cookie doughs freeze for up to 3 months, pumpkin roll freezes beautifully, and chess and buttermilk pies can be baked 1 to 2 days ahead and kept in the fridge.
What are easy Christmas desserts for beginners?
Peppermint bark, fudge, chocolate crinkle cookies and Dutch apple pie are all very forgiving. The bark and fudge need no oven at all, crinkle cookies are just rolled in powdered sugar, and Dutch apple pie has only one crust to roll.
How many desserts should I make for Christmas dinner?
For 8 to 12 guests, two pies plus one plate of cookies or candy is plenty. Plan about 1 slice of pie per person plus a few extra, since many people like to try two kinds. For bigger groups, add one pie for every 6 to 8 extra guests.
Which Christmas desserts are best for gifts?
Sturdy ones that keep: fudge, peppermint bark, shortbread, butter cookies, spritz, molasses cookies and mini fruitcakes. Pack them in a tin with parchment between the layers, and keep soft or frosted treats separate from crisp ones.
How far ahead can I bake Christmas cookies?
Sturdy cookies like shortbread, spritz and molasses cookies keep about 1 to 2 weeks in an airtight tin. For anything longer, freeze them baked or as dough for up to 3 months, then thaw in their container so they don't get damp.



