Old-Fashioned Buttermilk Pie Recipe
This buttermilk pie recipe makes a creamy, old-fashioned custard pie that tastes like a cross between vanilla pudding and cheesecake. It's sweet, a little tangy from the buttermilk, warm from a pinch of nutmeg, and it bakes up with a thin, golden, slightly crackly top. Southern grandmas have been making it for generations, mostly because it uses things you already have: buttermilk, sugar, butter, eggs and a spoonful of flour.
The filling takes about 10 minutes in one bowl with a whisk. The real secret is patience: bake it just until the center has a small wobble, then let it cool so it sets into smooth, silky slices.
Plan on about 5 1/2 hours start to finish, with roughly 40 minutes of hands-on time. It bakes 50 to 60 minutes at 350°F in a standard 9 inch pan and gives you 8 slices. The card below scales it for any pie pan or more than one pie.
Recipe card
Buttermilk Pie recipe
Pick your pie pan and how many you need. Every amount, the bake time and your start time update for you.
More free baking tools
What does buttermilk pie taste like?
If you've never had it, here's the closest description: a creamy vanilla custard with a gentle tang, like the filling of a cheesecake but lighter and softer. The top bakes into a thin, golden, sugary layer that crackles a little under your fork. The buttermilk doesn't make it sour. It just keeps all that sugar from tasting heavy, so you end up going back for another sliver.
It's a true Southern "desperation pie," the kind people made when fresh fruit and nuts weren't around. That's exactly why it's so handy in December, when you need one more pie and the pantry is all you've got.
Buttermilk pie vs chess pie: what's the difference?
They're cousins, and you'll see them side by side on a lot of Southern holiday tables. Here's how they compare:
| Buttermilk pie | Chess pie | |
|---|---|---|
| Liquid | 1 cup buttermilk | 1/4 cup milk |
| Thickener | Flour | Cornmeal and flour |
| Texture | Light, creamy, custardy | Dense, rich, almost fudgy |
| Flavor | Tangy vanilla with nutmeg | Sweet, buttery, a touch of tang from vinegar |
| Top | Golden, thin crackle | Golden, more pronounced crackle |
If you like tangy desserts, start with buttermilk pie. If you have a big sweet tooth, chess pie is your friend.
Can I use a buttermilk substitute?
Yes, in a pinch. Stir 1 tablespoon of lemon juice or white vinegar into a measuring cup, then add whole milk up to the 1 cup line and let it sit 5 minutes. If you go that route, leave out the lemon juice in the filling so it doesn't get too sharp. This guide to buttermilk substitutes covers more swaps, including plain yogurt thinned with milk, which gives you the creamiest result.
Honestly, though, real cultured buttermilk tastes best here, since it's the star. Low-fat buttermilk is what most stores sell, and it works perfectly.
Tips for a smooth, silky buttermilk pie
Bring everything to room temperature
Cold buttermilk and cold eggs can make the melted butter firm up into little flecks. Set them out for 30 to 45 minutes before you start, or warm the buttermilk for 15 seconds in the microwave.
Whisk the flour into the sugar first
Flour clumps when it hits liquid on its own. Mixing it with the sugar first keeps the filling lump-free.
Go gently
Whisk until smooth, then stop. Too much air puffs the pie up like a soufflé in the oven, and then it cracks and falls as it cools. If you see a lot of foam on top, skim it off with a spoon before baking.
Use the hot sheet pan
Setting the pie on a preheated sheet pan low in the oven helps the bottom crust bake through, and it makes carrying a very full, wobbly pie to the oven a lot less scary.
How do you know when buttermilk pie is done?
This is the part that makes or breaks it. Pull the pie when:
- The top is golden brown and looks set around the edges.
- The center, about the size of a coffee mug, still jiggles slightly when you nudge the pan. It should wobble like set gelatin, not slosh like liquid.
- The center reads about 180°F on an instant-read thermometer.
The custard keeps cooking and firming up as it cools. If you wait until the center is totally firm in the oven, you'll get a grainy, weepy pie with cracks. If the crust edge is browning too fast, add a foil ring after about 30 minutes.
Common buttermilk pie mistakes
| Problem | What usually happened | Fix next time |
|---|---|---|
| Runny center | Underbaked or cut while warm | Bake until only a small jiggle; cool at least 2 1/2 hours |
| Grainy, weepy texture | Overbaked | Pull it at about 180°F, while the center still wobbles |
| Big crack across the top | Too much air, overbaked, or cooled too fast in a drafty spot | Whisk gently; cool on a rack away from a cold window |
| Little butter flecks on top | Cold buttermilk or eggs hit the warm butter | Use room temperature ingredients |
| Soggy bottom crust | Rack too high or no hot sheet pan | Bake low in the oven on a preheated sheet pan |
| Top too dark | Oven running hot | Check with an oven thermometer; tent with foil |
Baking up high? Above 3,000 feet, drop the oven to 325°F and give it 10 to 15 extra minutes. The high altitude baking chart explains why custards behave differently up there.
Easy ways to dress up buttermilk pie
- Fresh berries: A handful of raspberries or blueberries on each slice looks beautiful and adds a nice tart bite.
- Whipped cream: A cloud of lightly sweetened homemade whipped cream is classic.
- Lemon buttermilk pie: Add 2 teaspoons finely grated lemon zest with the lemon juice.
- Holiday spice: Add 1/2 teaspoon cinnamon with the nutmeg, and dust the top with a little more nutmeg before baking.
- Brown butter: Brown the butter and let it cool before adding it. It gives the pie a toasty, nutty flavor.
- Coconut: Stir in 3/4 cup sweetened shredded coconut.
Can you make buttermilk pie ahead?
Yes, and it's actually better the next day. The flavor gets more rounded and the custard slices cleaner after a night in the fridge. Bake it 1 to 2 days ahead, cool it completely, then cover and refrigerate. Serve it chilled, or let it sit out about 30 minutes first.
Planning a whole holiday spread? Buttermilk pie bakes at 350°F, same as the long stretch of a pumpkin pie, so you can bake them back to back. You can also make the crust dough up to 3 months ahead and freeze it.
How do you store and freeze buttermilk pie?
- Counter: It's an egg custard, so keep it out no more than about 2 hours once it's cool.
- Fridge: Covered, up to 4 days.
- Freezer: Wrap the fully cooled pie or slices tightly in plastic wrap, then foil, and freeze up to 2 months. Thaw overnight in the fridge. The texture stays creamy, though the top loses a bit of its crackle.
Is buttermilk pie good for gifting?
It's lovely for a neighbor, a teacher or a potluck, as long as it stays cold. Bake it in a disposable foil pie pan, chill it overnight so it's firm for the car ride, and cover it well. Add a tag that says "keep refrigerated," and maybe tuck in a little bag of fresh berries for serving. It's simple, it's old-fashioned, and people who didn't grow up with it are always surprised how good it is.
Questions people ask
What does buttermilk pie taste like?
It tastes like a creamy vanilla custard with a light tang, a bit like a softer, lighter cheesecake filling. A pinch of nutmeg gives it a warm flavor, and the top bakes into a thin, golden, sugary layer.
Does buttermilk pie need to be refrigerated?
Yes. Buttermilk pie is an egg custard, so once it has cooled, cover it and keep it in the fridge for up to 4 days. Don't leave it on the counter for more than about 2 hours.
Why is my buttermilk pie runny?
It most likely came out of the oven too soon or was cut while it was still warm. Bake until the edges are set and only the center wobbles slightly, about 180°F, then cool it at least 2 1/2 hours so the custard can set.
Can I make buttermilk pie with regular milk?
You can make a quick substitute: stir 1 tablespoon lemon juice or white vinegar into 1 cup whole milk and let it sit 5 minutes. Leave out the lemon juice in the filling if you do. Plain milk on its own makes the pie bland and a bit thin.
What is the difference between buttermilk pie and chess pie?
Buttermilk pie uses a full cup of buttermilk, so it's lighter, creamier and tangier. Chess pie uses a little milk with cornmeal, so it's denser and sweeter with a crunchier top.
Can you freeze buttermilk pie?
Yes. Wrap the fully cooled pie or slices in plastic wrap and foil and freeze for up to 2 months. Thaw it overnight in the fridge and serve it cold or at room temperature.



