Italian Christmas Cookies (Starting With Soft Ricotta Cookies)
If there's one Italian Christmas cookie that shows up on almost every holiday tray, it's the ricotta cookie: a soft, pillowy little cake-like cookie with a sweet vanilla glaze and a shower of sprinkles. The ricotta keeps them tender and moist, and one batch makes about 6 dozen, which is exactly what you want for cookie trays, neighbor plates and cookie exchanges.
Plan on about 4 hours start to finish, but only about 1 hour of that is hands-on. The rest is chilling the dough, baking sheet after sheet and letting the glaze dry. The dough comes together in one bowl, and you don't need a rolling pin or cookie cutters.
The recipe card below makes a half batch, a batch and a half or a double, and switches every amount to grams. After the card you'll find 16 more Italian Christmas cookies (pizzelle, anise knots, rainbow cookies, biscotti and more) plus tips for building a gorgeous Italian cookie tray.
Recipe card
Italian Ricotta Cookies recipe
Pick your cookie size and how many you need. Every amount, the bake time and your start time update for you.
More free baking tools
Tips for the best Italian ricotta cookies
- Use whole-milk ricotta. Part-skim works, but whole milk gives a softer, richer cookie. If your ricotta looks watery, drain it in a fine sieve for 20 minutes first, or the cookies spread.
- Chill the dough. It starts out sticky, almost like cake batter. Thirty minutes in the fridge makes it easy to scoop and keeps the cookies nicely domed.
- Watch the bottoms, not the tops. Ricotta cookies stay pale on top when they're done. Lift one with a spatula. If the bottom is light golden, pull the sheet.
- Glaze completely cool cookies. Warm cookies melt the glaze into a thin, see-through layer. Cool ones give you that thick, white, bakery-style coat.
- Sprinkle fast. Glaze sets in a minute or two. Dip 5 or 6 cookies, sprinkle them, then do the next few.
Want a lemon version? Use the zest of 2 lemons in the dough and swap the milk in the glaze for fresh lemon juice. They're bright and lovely next to the chocolate cookies on a tray.
16 more Italian Christmas cookies
Italian Christmas cookies come from every region of Italy, plus a few that were born in Italian-American bakeries. Here are the classics, grouped by texture so you can build a tray with a little of everything.
Soft and glazed
- Anise knot cookies (anginetti). Soft little cookies tied in a knot, glazed and sprinkled. The classic flavor is anise (a gentle licorice taste), and lemon is just as popular. Use anise extract in the dough and the glaze.
- Italian lemon drop cookies. Round, cakey cookies with a lemon glaze. They're a close cousin of the ricotta cookie, made without the cheese, and they're a great pick for anyone who doesn't love anise.
- Struffoli. Not quite a cookie, but it's on almost every Neapolitan Christmas table: tiny fried dough balls tossed in warm honey and piled into a wreath with colored sprinkles. Kids love pulling them off one at a time.
Crisp and buttery
- Pizzelle. Thin, crisp waffle cookies pressed in a pizzelle iron with a snowflake pattern. They're usually flavored with anise or vanilla, and they're beautiful dusted with powdered sugar. You need the special iron, but the batter takes 10 minutes.
- Italian butter cookies. The bakery-box classic: piped rosettes and S shapes, some dipped in chocolate, some with a dot of jam. Our spritz cookies recipe makes a very similar dough, and you can pipe it with a bag and star tip instead of a press.
- Biscotti. Twice-baked, crunchy and made for dunking in coffee or hot cocoa. Try almond, cranberry pistachio or chocolate chip, and dip one end in white chocolate for Christmas. They keep for weeks, so they're ideal for mailing.
- Sesame cookies (biscotti regina). Sicilian cookies rolled in sesame seeds. They're lightly sweet and crunchy with a toasty flavor, and they're often the first ones grandpa reaches for.
- Torcetti. Little twists from Piedmont, rolled in sugar before baking, so they come out crisp and caramelized on the outside.
- Italian butter balls. Tender, crumbly butter cookies rolled in powdered sugar, sometimes called Italian wedding cookies. If you're baking for someone with a nut allergy, our snowball cookies without nuts are the same idea.
Almond and hazelnut
- Amaretti. Almond cookies made with egg whites, sugar and ground almonds. Some are crisp and some are soft and chewy with a crackly top. Most are naturally gluten free.
- Pignoli. Chewy almond paste cookies covered in pine nuts. They're one of the priciest cookies on the tray because of the pine nuts, and one of the most loved.
- Ricciarelli. Soft, chewy almond cookies from Siena, with a cracked powdered sugar top and a hint of orange zest.
- Italian rainbow cookies. Three thin layers of almond cake (green, white and red), sandwiched with raspberry or apricot jam and topped with chocolate. They're an Italian-American bakery favorite and take some time, but they freeze beautifully.
- Baci di dama. The name means "lady's kisses." Two tiny hazelnut butter cookies sandwiched with a little chocolate. Toasting the hazelnuts first makes a big difference. Here's how to toast nuts evenly.
Spiced, fruity and chocolatey
- Cuccidati (Sicilian fig cookies). Buttery pastry wrapped around a filling of dried figs, raisins, nuts, orange zest and spices, then glazed and sprinkled. We make the filling moist with orange juice and a spoonful of honey.
- Chocolate spice cookies. Soft, cakey cocoa cookies with cinnamon and cloves, glazed on top. Some families call them "chocolate meatballs" because of their round shape. Mostaccioli, a diamond-shaped cousin from Naples, get a chocolate coating instead.
And if you just need one more crowd-pleaser? Chocolate crinkles and gingerbread aren't Italian, but nobody's ever complained to see them on the tray. Our Christmas desserts list has more ideas.
What Italian Christmas desserts go with the cookies?
If you're planning a full Italian-style dessert spread for Christmas Eve or Christmas Day, these are the classics to add alongside the cookie tray:
- Panettone. The tall, domed sweet bread from Milan, studded with candied orange and raisins. Most families buy it, and leftover slices make amazing French toast.
- Pandoro. Panettone's plain cousin from Verona: a star-shaped, buttery golden bread dusted with powdered sugar like a snowy mountain.
- Torrone. Chewy or crunchy nougat made with honey, egg whites and almonds or hazelnuts. Cut it into small pieces for the tray.
- Panforte. A dense, chewy cake from Siena packed with nuts, dried fruit, honey and spices. A thin slice goes a long way.
How do you build an Italian Christmas cookie tray?
A good tray has a mix of shapes, colors and textures. For a tray that looks like it came from a bakery:
- Pick 4 to 6 kinds. One soft glazed cookie (ricotta or anise), one crisp (pizzelle or biscotti), one almond (amaretti or pignoli), one chocolate and one showpiece (rainbow cookies). That covers everyone.
- Plan about 3 to 4 cookies per guest, or 5 to 6 if the tray is the main dessert.
- Keep soft and crisp apart. Soft, moist cookies like ricotta cookies make crisp ones go soft. Use small paper liners or separate the sections.
- Stand pizzelle and biscotti up along the back or the center for height.
- Add color with sprinkles and powdered sugar, and tuck in a few rosemary sprigs for a festive look.
Packing tins for neighbors or teachers? Our guide to how many cookies fit in a gift tin helps you plan how many batches to bake.
Can you freeze Italian Christmas cookies?
Most of them, yes, which makes December much calmer. Here's a quick guide:
| Cookie | Room temperature, airtight | Freezer |
|---|---|---|
| Ricotta cookies | Up to 3 days (or the fridge for up to a week) | Up to 3 months, best frozen unglazed |
| Anise knots and lemon drops | Up to 5 days | Up to 3 months, unglazed |
| Pizzelle | Up to 2 weeks in a tin | Up to 3 months |
| Biscotti | Up to 3 weeks | Up to 3 months |
| Italian butter cookies | Up to 2 weeks | Up to 3 months |
| Amaretti and pignoli | Up to 1 week | Up to 3 months |
| Rainbow cookies | Up to 1 week, covered | Up to 2 months |
For glazed cookies, freeze them plain, then thaw and glaze a day or two before serving. The glaze stays bright and doesn't get sticky. See our full list of Christmas cookies that freeze well for the rest of your baking.
Common ricotta cookie mistakes
- Watery ricotta. Extra liquid makes flat, spread-out cookies. Drain it if it looks wet.
- Skipping the chill. Warm dough spreads into thin discs instead of soft domes.
- Waiting for brown tops. By the time the tops brown, the cookies are dry. Go by the light golden bottoms.
- Glaze too thin. It soaks in and turns see-through. Aim for the thickness of school glue, adding milk only a teaspoon at a time.
- Stacking too soon. Wait until the glaze is completely dry, or the cookies glue together in the tin.
Swaps and variations
| Want to change | Try this |
|---|---|
| Anise flavor | Swap the vanilla in the dough for 1 1/2 teaspoons anise extract, and use 1/2 teaspoon in the glaze |
| Almond flavor | Add 1 teaspoon almond extract to the dough and use almond in the glaze |
| Lemon | Zest of 2 lemons in the dough, lemon juice instead of milk in the glaze |
| Orange | Zest of 1 orange in the dough, orange juice in the glaze |
| Chocolate chip | Fold 1 cup of mini chocolate chips into the dough and skip the glaze |
| Christmas colors | Tint half the glaze pale green and half pale red with a tiny bit of gel coloring |
Baking a few batches for a cookie exchange? Our baking tools include a recipe converter that scales any recipe in one step, and a baking time calculator for every sheet.
Questions people ask
What are the most popular Italian Christmas cookies?
Ricotta cookies, anise knot cookies, pizzelle, biscotti, rainbow cookies, Italian butter cookies, amaretti and pignoli are the classics. Sicilian fig cookies (cuccidati) and sesame cookies are big favorites too.
How do you know when ricotta cookies are done?
Look at the bottoms, not the tops. Ricotta cookies stay pale on top when they're baked through. They're done when they're puffed, the tops look dry and the bottoms are light golden, usually 12 to 14 minutes at 350°F.
How long do ricotta cookies last?
About 3 days in an airtight container at room temperature, or up to a week in the fridge. For longer, freeze them unglazed for up to 3 months, then thaw and glaze a day or two before serving.
Why are my ricotta cookies flat?
Usually the ricotta was watery or the dough wasn't chilled. Drain wet ricotta in a sieve for 20 minutes, chill the dough for 30 minutes and bake on cool baking sheets.
What are Italian Christmas biscuits?
Biscuits is the British word for cookies, so Italian Christmas biscuits are the same as Italian Christmas cookies. The name often means biscotti in particular, the twice-baked crunchy cookies that keep for weeks.
How many cookies should I put on an Italian cookie tray?
Plan about 3 to 4 cookies per guest, or 5 to 6 if the tray is the main dessert. Pick 4 to 6 kinds with a mix of soft, crisp, almond and chocolate cookies.



